Landlord Failed to Prevent a Crime; Can The Tenant Sue The Landlord For Injuries?

Posted By on November 6, 2014

Last Update: 01/05/16

Home is your sanctuary, or at least it should be, and just because you rent doesn’t mean you don’t get to relax and feel safe there. That is something that we all deserve to enjoy. That feeling of safety is something that Florida law protects, and when a landlord fails to fulfill his obligations to provide a safe environment and a tenant becomes a victim of a preventable or foreseeable crime that results in an injury, that failure gives rise to a personal injury claim of “negligent security.”   Basically, negligent security is the failure of a landlord to protect and provide a safe environment by failing to do simple things like providing adequate lighting or providing adequate security measures at or near your home.

Florida landlords are held accountable to provide a safe environment under laws passed by the Florida Legislature, like the Florida Residential Landlord and Tenant Act, as well as case law precedent, both of which define Florida’s premises liability law. Tenants who are harmed by someone in the commission of a crime either in their rental home or on the premises (such as the stairwell leading to their apartment) may be able to recover damages from their landlord for claims including medical expenses, lost wages, lost earning capacity, pain and suffering, and more.

 

 

Crimes That No One Expected vs. Crimes That Could Be Foreseen

There are exceptions to the law holding Florida landlord’s liable to their tenants for harm and injury suffered in a crime. That is, where the crime that occurred is so shocking and unexpected that no one — tenant or landlord — would have expected it to happen. In those cases, Florida law will not hold the landlord accountable to the tenant for the tenant’s injuries and damages.

However, and this is true for most tenant crime injury cases, landlords will be held liable for what happened to the tenant if the criminal act is something that was reasonably foreseen or anticipated. Likewise, if the crime is committed in such a way that the landlord’s failure to comply with the Florida Residential Landlord and Tenant Act (like failing to change the keys on an apartment before renting it to the new tenant) contributed to the event, then the landlord will be liable for the tenant’s harm.

Read: A Tenant, Who Is Also A Rape Victim, Sues Landlord and Wins: Example of a Florida Case Involving Negligent Security By A Landlord

What Landlords Should Do to Protect Tenants

Landlords need to take reasonable action to protect their tenants from foreseeable harm from criminal activity in the area. What that action may be depends upon the particular circumstances. If there have been robberies in the dimly lit parking lot, then the landlord needs to make sure that the parking areas have good lighting that works. If there have been rapes in the area around campus, then the landlord needs to make sure that tenants have properly locking doors and windows, properly lit common walkways, etc.

Landlords leasing residences to tenants in communities with high crime rates according to police data will need to take more proactive action to protect tenants than landlords renting similar types of dwellings but which are located in low crime areas. High crime area apartment complexes may need privacy gates and security fencing with security cameras, for example, while low crime area apartment complexes may not.

In other words, what your landlord needs to do for you to provide a safe environment may be different than what your friend’s landlord does for him across town. The landlord’s security duties are tied to the specific circumstances surrounding the rental property and what reasonable actions should be taken there.

Other steps landlords should take include performing background checks on all tenants and employees and, in some instances, hiring full time or part time security.

What Should You Do?

If you or a loved one has been hurt during the commission of a crime in a rented residence, then you may be able to pursue a civil lawsuit against your landlord for “negligent security” and recover damages. Florida landlords are responsible for protecting their tenants from reasonably foreseeable criminal conduct as well as complying with safety issues delineated in the Florida Residential Landlord and Tenant Act. Criminal prosecutors can be helpful to crime victims in many ways; however, they do not pursue these kinds of claims. For civil actions against a landlord, injured tenants need a Florida personal injury lawyer to help them.

A good piece of advice if you have been the victim of a crime and believe it resulted from your landlord’s negligence, is to speak with an experienced personal injury lawyer before you file a claim to learn about some of the issues that can arise with these claims, including the type of evidence needed to prove a claim and the type and amount of damages you can recover. Most personal injury lawyers, like Alan Sackrin, will offer a free initial consultation (over the phone or in person) to answer your questions.

Related:

_______________

Do you have questions or comments? Then please feel free to send Alan an email or call him now at (954) 458-8655.

 

 

If you found this information helpful, please share this article and bookmark it for your future reference.

Comments

2 Responses to “Landlord Failed to Prevent a Crime; Can The Tenant Sue The Landlord For Injuries?”

  1. Alan Sackrin says:

    We are not allowed to answer personal questions in blog comments, so we would ask you to feel free to contact our offices if you’d like to discuss the situation with us over the phone. There’s no charge, we have a free initial consultation policy here. Thanks for writing!

  2. Ms. C (missy) says:

    Should I rightfully be Compensated.- How to handle similiar type situations.

    I have rented a small space on landlords property,like neighbors,can see when car is parked and not alway.
    Landlord’s thirty something son got out of jail from PA. I did not immediately know. Until always hear and additional voice on their property, then finally was informed..
    Ex-drug addict Life issues. to the point his own parents (the landlords) kicked him out/banned them from their house,eventually landed in trouble up in PA where he served prison time..

    Landlord husband recent passed away. Whole atmosphere CHANGE MORE. HE start being inconsiderate and and retaliatory towards me concerning simple, yet significant things.on the place where I rent. Begin to see him with this street girl come out of the house. NEVER seen before until he there. she parked in my parking space. more than once. I address it with widow. I come another time, 11pm at night , Street girl car in my spot as he clearly SEES my car but continues to buff the bumper, as if more important not move. Didi mention he doesnt work.
    I address it again. Two weeks again the landlord widow informed she is leaving her house in urgency because she fears her life, He keeps asking her if there is an inheritance Or Life insurance over the recent passing of the landlord husband. Believes he is back on drugs, as his older sister saw stuff in her garage after the funeral.

    She told me, Well I don’t know what you are going to do. But I am leaving. I was like OK did not KNOW how extreme but stayed another night. he last night before stuff hit the fan I am suddenly hearing excessive movement in middle of the night on property,wake up to NO water coming out of faucet. NEVER before.
    THEN found out day later that TWO guns were missing from their home.
    I was upset and told her did not know how serious this was I would have packed things up as well. I had to scramble to find a place to stay on TIGHT Budget, NO clothes on me,nothing for TWO days, on in work week & just gave her rent week and half ago.
    To this day she has Not been back on her own property for sake of her peace of mind safety, yet is OK for ME..a tentant.??

    There was an intervention and moved him out to a hotel. They hope he doesnt mess up,so he can go to a Rehab finally-

    IS she liable in ANY way for the costs incurred for my saftey and expenses that occurred KNOWINGLY from her problematic son.?All she says is sorry- I want more than that

Leave a Reply

Please note: Comment moderation is currently enabled so there will be a delay between when you post your comment and when it shows up. Patience is a virtue; there is no need to re-submit your comment.